The short answer: Digital Cheddar’s Google reviews describe an agency that produces measurable results, communicates quickly, and behaves like part of the client’s team. The current Google listing shows a 5.0 rating across 14 reviews, with every rating at five stars. Thirteen reviewers also left written feedback. The pattern is not subtle: clients repeatedly mention stronger sales, better campaign performance, responsive service, practical strategy, and people who are refreshingly easy to work with.
That last part matters more than some agencies like to admit. A marketing partner can build an impressive dashboard and still make every meeting feel like a hostage negotiation conducted in acronyms. Digital Cheddar’s reviews point in the opposite direction: clear recommendations, hands-on support, fast responses, and an easy-going team that keeps the work moving.
What Do Digital Cheddar Google Reviews Say
Across the complete live review set, five themes appear again and again: measurable business impact, responsive communication, collaborative partnership, cross-channel expertise, and flexibility. Individual reviewers describe different services, industries, and campaign goals, but the experience they report is remarkably consistent.
-
Clients connect Digital Cheddar’s work to sales growth, stronger traffic and engagement, better campaign performance, and improved return on investment.
-
Reviewers describe the team as responsive, communicative, efficient, available, and quick to solve problems.
-
Several clients say Digital Cheddar felt like an extension of their internal marketing team.
-
The work spans websites, SEO, SEM, paid social, organic social, branding, creative, tracking, reporting, outreach, and community communications.
-
Todd Riegler and the team are praised for listening, adapting, explaining decisions, and keeping the process enjoyable.
In other words, the reviews are not 14 versions of ‘nice people, good job.’ They describe what Digital Cheddar did, how the team worked, and what changed afterward. That specificity is what makes a review useful.
Results Are the Most Important Part of the Pattern
Marketing reviews often drift toward compliments about attractive creative or pleasant meetings. Those are welcome, but businesses hire an agency to improve something: revenue, demand, efficiency, awareness, lead quality, customer engagement, or some combination of the above. Digital Cheddar’s reviews repeatedly connect the work to outcomes.
One client says Digital Cheddar helped grow sales over multiple years and delivered “more results for less money.”
Another reports that home sales took off with the team’s help. A website client describes a noticeable increase in traffic and customer engagement. A multi-channel client highlights a data-driven paid media strategy built to maximize return on investment. Others mention stellar metrics, stronger SEO and SEM performance, and better-informed marketing decisions.
These are not identical goals, which is the point. Digital Cheddar does not appear to force every client into the same campaign template and then act surprised when a local builder, a national consumer brand, and a community organization need different things. The reviews describe recommendations tied to the client’s actual business objective. Revolutionary stuff, apparently.
Customer Service Is Not Treated Like a Side Quest
The second strongest theme is communication. Reviewers mention quick responses, availability, efficiency, timeliness, patience, and attention to detail. One client praises the team as “super communicative and efficient.”
Another says every question was answered quickly and every detail was handled with care. A community communications partner calls Digital Cheddar easy to work with and quick to respond. Several reviews describe the team as consistently available when a client needed guidance or a problem solved.
That is not merely a warm-and-fuzzy benefit. Fast, direct communication protects performance. Campaigns change. Platforms change. Budgets move. Tracking breaks five minutes before a stakeholder meeting because tracking has impeccable comedic timing. An agency that responds quickly can make decisions while they still matter.
Clients Describe a Real Partnership
Multiple reviewers use partnership language rather than vendor language. Two describe Digital Cheddar as an “extension of our team.”
That phrase carries weight because it suggests more than friendly service. It means the agency understands the goal, participates in the decision-making process, shares useful learning, and stays close enough to the work to spot opportunities. One reviewer says the insights from a campaign were strong enough to inform an entire marketing plan. Another praises the team for making “data-driven decisions.”
Digital Cheddar’s lean model supports that kind of relationship. The company was founded by Todd Riegler in 2014 and intentionally remains connected to clients rather than building layers of account management between the strategist and the person paying the invoice. The reviews suggest clients notice the difference.
Todd Riegler Gets Mentioned for the Right Reasons
Todd’s background combines sales, sales management, digital marketing, paid search, tracking, and agency leadership. That mix shows up in the way reviewers describe his work. They do not only praise technical expertise. They mention listening, learning the product, understanding the assignment, and presenting specific recommendations tied to business goals.
One detailed review describes a difficult launch assignment: build awareness and optimize conversions for a new-to-market brand and product line. Todd listened to the goals, learned the product, applied Google Ads and measurement expertise, and coordinated paid search with social advertising. The same reviewer also calls him easy-going, flexible, nimble, patient, and fun. That is a useful combination when a campaign is starting from scratch and the brief is still evolving in real time.
Clients also mention Kim, Brooke, and the broader Digital Cheddar team for creative collaboration, paid social strategy, campaign support, and fresh ideas. The recurring message is not that one charismatic founder parachutes into the kickoff call and disappears. It is that the people doing the work stay involved.
The Reviews Cover More Than One Marketing Service
The review set also reveals range. Digital Cheddar is evaluated across multiple disciplines, including website development, paid search, paid social, SEO, SEM, organic social content, branding, creative development, measurement, and community outreach.
That breadth matters because modern marketing problems rarely respect departmental boundaries. A campaign can have smart targeting and weak creative. A beautiful website can have poor tracking. Paid search can drive clicks to a landing page that converts like a screen door on a submarine. The reviews show Digital Cheddar working across those connections instead of treating each channel as a separate little kingdom.
For businesses that want one accountable partner, this is a practical advantage. Strategy, execution, creative, and measurement can work together, and the client spends less time translating between specialists who apparently communicate only through forwarded email chains.
What Makes These Reviews Credible
A five-star average is impressive, but the useful evidence is inside the written feedback. Strong reviews usually include four things: a recognizable business challenge, a description of the work, an explanation of the working relationship, and a result or recommendation. Digital Cheddar’s written reviews frequently include all four.
-
Specific challenges: launching a new product, relaunching a website, improving sales, coordinating paid channels, or strengthening outreach.
-
Specific services: Google Ads, tracking, SEM, paid social, websites, creative content, SEO, branding, and community communications.
-
Specific working behaviors: listening, responding quickly, staying available, adapting recommendations, and sharing useful learning.
-
Specific outcomes: increased sales, better traffic and engagement, stronger campaign performance, useful strategic insights, and measurable return.
The reviews also span several years, which helps distinguish a durable service pattern from one unusually enthusiastic week. Older clients praise SEO, SEM, branding, social media, and sales impact. Newer clients describe websites, paid media, cross-channel strategy, communication, and measurable performance. The services have expanded, but the emphasis on results and responsiveness has stayed consistent.
Is Digital Cheddar Easy to Work With
According to the Google reviews, yes. Clients repeatedly describe Digital Cheddar as collaborative, responsive, flexible, hands-on, patient, resourceful, and enjoyable to work with. Those words show up in different reviews from different types of organizations, which makes the pattern more meaningful than any single testimonial.
Digital Cheddar also states that it does not require long-term contracts or impose a monthly minimum. The company chooses clients carefully and focuses on mutual fit. That operating model aligns with the review language: clients describe direct relationships, specific recommendations, and a team that stays close to the work.
Ease of doing business does not mean low standards or vague strategy. It means fewer unnecessary layers, honest communication, and a clear connection between the work and the business objective. You can have rigor without turning every status meeting into a ceremonial reading of the project-management software.
Can Digital Cheddar Handle Complex and Large Scale Work
The reviews provide evidence that the team can manage complex assignments involving multiple channels, stakeholders, and performance goals. Clients describe coordinated paid search and social advertising, website relaunches combined with SEM and paid social, new product launches, ongoing SEO and SEM programs, and campaign learning that shaped broader marketing plans.
Digital Cheddar’s broader client history includes recognized national brands as well as local and regional businesses. The advantage of the lean structure is not that the work stays small. It is that senior people remain accessible while the scope grows.
What Prospective Clients Should Take Away
Digital Cheddar’s Google reviews suggest a straightforward value proposition: thoughtful digital strategy, measurable execution, responsive service, and people who make the work easier rather than heavier. The agency’s strongest differentiator may be the combination. Plenty of firms can talk about performance. Plenty can be pleasant. The reviews describe a team that does both.
If your business wants a marketing partner that can connect websites, search, social, creative, tracking, and reporting to actual business goals, the review history is a strong signal. If you also prefer direct answers, flexible collaboration, and fewer meetings whose primary outcome is scheduling the next meeting, even better.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Many Google Reviews Does Digital Cheddar Have
The current live Google listing shows 14 reviews and a 5.0 overall rating. All 14 ratings are five stars. Thirteen reviewers included written feedback, while one left a five-star rating without written comments. Review totals can change over time, so the live listing is the best source for the latest count.
What Do Clients Praise Most About Digital Cheddar
Clients most often praise measurable results, quick communication, responsive service, hands-on collaboration, practical recommendations, and the team’s ability to work across multiple digital marketing channels.
Do the Reviews Mention Business Results
Yes. Reviews mention sales growth, increased website traffic and customer engagement, stronger SEO and SEM performance, improved return on investment, better campaign metrics, and strategic learning that influenced larger marketing plans.
Do Clients Mention Todd Riegler
Yes. Reviewers describe Todd as knowledgeable, responsive, flexible, patient, easy-going, and fun to work with. They also praise his ability to understand business goals, learn a product, explain recommendations, and use paid search and measurement expertise to improve performance.
What Services Appear in Digital Cheddar Reviews
The reviews mention website development, Google Ads, SEM, SEO, paid social advertising, organic social content, branding, creative work, tracking, reporting, campaign strategy, outreach, and community communications.
